deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
×

×

Beginning of an art journey

Journal Entry: Tue Jun 26, 2012, 9:22 AM
  • Listening to: Go-aqualia
  • Reading: imagine fx
  • Watching: Game of thrones
  • Playing: Battlefield 3
  • Eating: my pride
  • Drinking: My own tears

3,280

70 86 0

Details

Stats

Submitted on
June 26, 2012
Views
3,280 (2 today)
Favourites
70 (who?)
Comments
86
URL
Thumb
Only verified accounts can report policy violations. Please check your email and click on the verification link.
* Required field
Add a Comment:
 
love 4 4 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconjjshaver:
~JJShaver Jun 30, 2012  Professional General Artist
Imitation is the simple form of flattery...unless china is ripping off your stuff. Great gallery and an excellent read. Thank you.
Reply
:iconkeyshe54:
~Keyshe54 Jun 30, 2012   Traditional Artist
I appreciate your opinion and the way you are taking and choose to deal with it, but it is stealing-ish. :/

They work right off you and your color and composition, and so many that's the key issue. Some are more their own, but others are a little close to be not seen as taking/stealing/borrowing from you a little. But it's nice to see you aren't bothered by it though, so no harm done by him. They are leaning art sure... but a little in a stinky way(maybe not intentional though) and practicing something that isn't that great of a practice. This person should be giving you 'some' credit for their 'inspiration' and work on not working's' closely off others work with out permission. It's probably going to upset people down the line and it's a little dishonest.
Reply
:iconxaii-disconnection:
Your opinion is one to appreciate on this topic. The honesty makes it even better. It has opened my eyes a little bit more, to the art world.

Your art has helped create yet another art-explorer. It is wonderful that you have taken in their art interpretation so happily!

Human nature encourages copying before self-adventure.
Reply
:iconkitsuru:
~Kitsuru Jun 29, 2012   Digital Artist
They do look similar, but i agree with you! Everyone has to start somewhere.
Reply
:iconuna-aberration:
~una-aberration Jun 28, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Imitation is the greatest form of flattery. =)
Reply
:iconluke-crowe:
=luke-crowe Jun 28, 2012  Hobbyist Artist
If I were to do similar work, with my lack of art skills, I would feel too guilty not to post the reference I used. I find it offensive that this artist used work from Deviantart and does not give credit. It may be legal, but its poor manners in my opinion. Especially when there are comments on his page that suggest that his work is not derived directly from yours.
Reply
:iconkeyshe54:
~Keyshe54 Jun 30, 2012   Traditional Artist
I believe it's starting to border on the illegal... one don't have copyright to a theme and an idea of art. But the art piece itself any original character design and 'close' likeness. Composition well. Some are totally illegal inspiration, other are very close and when you put together HOW many. Elsevilla could probably take it to court if he cared. But since no many was made there isn't anything to win against really. And Els doesn't mind. Which over all is very good of him, but leaving this artists to keep using other work isn't really a good thing. Someone will be hurt by it some time, and it's not a good practice for him to do so. He could really get in trouble some time down the line.

He should GIVE credit at least to be honest and polite when he is borrowing 'heavily' such as in the grey girl, green witch, the lineart and maybe the knight fighting the monster.

Also should get permission too if he's doing this with other artists so closely...
Reply
:iconelsevilla:
=elsevilla Jun 28, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
I think its more like inspired, i think when he draws more and learn composition he will take his own risks in this art journey.
Reply
:iconluke-crowe:
=luke-crowe Jun 29, 2012  Hobbyist Artist
I may have been a little emotional with that comment. I still watched him, I hope he improves.
Reply
:icondeckboy:
~Deckboy Jun 27, 2012  Hobbyist Artist
Wow. What an honor to have someone copy you!! I applaud you for your understanding of the other artist!

I think a big thing to mention here, too is that the other artist is not just copy + pasting your art and trying to sell the art. In fact, only one of those pictures is even for sale as a print, (the first one listed) and that one is arguably entirely different subject matter. Composition wise, and coloring wise, it may be some form of copy, but the subject matter is very different. When viewing the pictures it's rather obvious that they are not done by the same person - unlike how most "art thieves" just download the original picture and do subtle changes. (like change the background or something)

I love your perspective on this issue - totally got me to thinking!
Reply
Add a Comment: